Oscars
This year’s Oscars are, without doubt, the best overall crop of performances that I have seen in a while. While it may seem as though last year was pretty bad for movies, the good ones were truly outstanding. Unfortunately, in making my decisions, I’m handicapped by not having seen all the contenders, Mystic River and Master and Commander foremost among them.
That said, I think that by far the two best films of last year were Pirates and Lost in Translation. If I had to pick one of the two, I would be torn. I think Lord the Rings deserves a special place in history, and I think it deserves an Oscar, but so do the others. LOTRs greatness stems from the fact that it is one movie in 3 parts. The movie as a whole deserves an Oscar, but I don’t think that any of the three discreet films do. LOTR will be remembered for a long time, even without an Oscar (just look at Star Wars, or Indiana Jones), so I don’t feel like I’d be shortchanging it by not giving it best picture.
Since Pirates isn’t nominated for best picture, I would give it to Lost in Translation. However, I would definitely give Johnny Depp the award for leading actor. It seems common knowledge that comedy is harder than drama, and Depp practically invented someone from another planet, and did it so believably that he (with Geoffrey Rush’s help) carried the whole movie. I would only hesitate in my decision because of Bill Murray’s performance. While not detracting anything from his world class performance, I would attribute much of his success to Sofia Coppola’s writing.
For directing, I think that Peter Jackson deserves it hands down. Direction is bringing all the parts of a movie together, and while Lost in Translation was beautifully rendered, LOTR was a project of hurculean proportions. To command not only the actors but all the CGI (cities whose beauty is matched only by Blade Runner and 5th Element), and to create so seamlessly the environment of Middle Earth outpaces all the others.
I haven’t seen enough of the other categories to speak with any confidence to their merits. In any case, it’s exciting to have so many worthy films nominated. It’s been quite a long time since I could say that not only am I torn between which films are the best, but that I don’t know which films the academy will select.



